Optimizing the Cincinnati Reds’ Infield Glut and the Potential Return of Joey Votto

The Cincinnati Reds are facing a difficult decision regarding the $20 million contract option for their 40-year-old first baseman, Joey Votto. Many fans and analysts believe that the team has too many talented young infielders to justify exercising the option. However, this decision is just one of many factors at play for the Reds.

Team president Nick Krall stands by the Reds’ trade deadline plan despite the playoff results. The Reds have also settled their catching question by extending Luke Maile for one year and $3.5 million. When asked about the Reds’ roster entering 2024, Krall emphasizes the goal of upgrading the club this offseason.

While the abundance of young infielders is a factor to consider, it is not enough to completely rule out the option from the team’s perspective. Some of the impressive rookie talents that finished the season in the Reds’ lineup may start the 2024 season in the minors. Krall acknowledges that this is a possibility and believes it may be necessary for some players.

If spring training were to start tomorrow, the roster would likely include Jonathan India, Matt McLain, and Spencer Steer as the infielders, with Steer potentially playing in the outfield as well. Elly De La Cruz, Christian Encarnacion-Strand, and Noelvi Marte, who made their debuts after May, will have to compete for roster spots in spring training. Nick Senzel, the third baseman and center fielder, is currently on the roster.

The bottom line is that the Reds’ infield group is filled with young and talented players who may not all have a spot on the roster next season. This creates room for a veteran like Votto, who has a strong history with the organization, to make a valuable contribution to the team.

Ultimately, the decision regarding Votto’s option will involve owner Bob Castellini. The Reds are currently in budget meetings, and the deadline for the option decision is approaching. Krall assures that the organization is still working through their offseason plans and have not made any decisions yet.

The surplus of infielders and the lack of experience within the group will certainly impact the decision. It is also likely that one or two exciting rookies from the 2023 season will start in Triple-A Louisville. Krall emphasizes the need to keep an open mind and considers all aspects of improving the club, including the starting rotation.

Nick Lodolo and Graham Ashcraft, who were in the opening rotation, ended the season on the injured list but are expected to be back at full strength next spring. They will join Hunter Greene, Andrew Abbott, and Brandon Williamson in the projected top five. Prospects like Connor Phillips, Carson Spiers, and Lyon Richardson are also in the mix for starting roles.

With the surplus of pitchers and potential infielders, Louisville is likely to receive a number of talented players who played a part in the Reds’ success this year. Thus, the apparent infield glut may not be as significant as initially perceived, especially when it comes to the decision regarding Votto.

In conclusion, the Cincinnati Reds are facing a complex decision regarding the return of Joey Votto, given their abundance of talented young infielders. While this may be a factor, it is not the sole determinant of the decision. The team is considering various aspects, and owner Bob Castellini will play a significant role in the final decision. The Reds’ offseason plans are still being worked out, and the deadline for the option decision is approaching. Overall, the surplus of infielders and pitchers may not be as problematic as it initially seems, allowing room for a potential return of Votto.

Reference

David Rodriguez

David Rodriguez brings the excitement of Major League Baseball to readers. With a deep appreciation for America’s pastime, he covers the latest MLB news, scores, and player achievements, keeping fans up to date with their favorite teams and players.