Is Chris Paddack a Reliable Starting Rotation Option for the 2024 Twins?

When we look back at the Twins’ 2023 season, we remember the standout postseason performances of players like Royce Lewis and Pablo López, as well as the end of the team’s 18-game playoff losing streak. But mixed in with these headline-grabbing moments, one more quietly compelling story unfolded as starter-turned-temporary-reliever Chris Paddack showed signs of dominance that hinted at great potential.

Throughout the 2023 season, fans wondered when Paddack, who had undergone Tommy John surgery, would return to the field. Finally, on September 24, an imminent debut was foiled by a rain delay, shifting his return to a September 26 game against the Oakland Athletics. Despite initial struggles, Paddack soon bounced back and found his rhythm against the Colorado Rockies, ultimately securing a spot on the Twins’ Wild Card Series roster.

In the postseason, Paddack’s performances against the Houston Astros truly shone, with an impressive 0.27 WHIP and 14.7 K/9, further solidifying his potential as a top-tier pitcher.

As we move into 2024, the focus is on the Twins’ intended role for Paddack as a mid-rotation starter. However, this plan has stirred unexpected controversy, particularly in light of recent departures from the team’s pitching staff. Keith Law’s article in The Athletic drew attention to the Twins’ lack of starters and potential rotation options, but his lack of mention of Paddack has raised eyebrows and sparked questions about his predicted role in the 2024 lineup.

In response, Law highlighted Paddack’s injury history and low innings pitched, suggesting that the team’s optimism might be unfounded. Yet, Paddack’s 2023 performances and the Twins’ knack for nurturing pitching talent offer compelling reasons to remain hopeful about his future impact.

The debate is open: was it fair to discuss Balazovic while omitting Paddack? Will the Twins’ faith in Paddack pay off, and how will he perform in 2024? Join the conversation with your thoughts below.