Bob Melvin emerges as Giants’ top managerial candidate after Padres allow him to interview: Sources

The San Francisco Giants have been given permission to interview Bob Melvin, the current manager of the San Diego Padres, for their vacant managerial position, according to sources. This potential move would see Melvin join a rival team in the National League West after a turbulent season with the Padres. Melvin is now the leading candidate to replace Gabe Kapler as the Giants’ manager.

The Padres’ president of baseball operations, A.J. Preller, and Melvin both declined to comment on the situation. While they previously announced their return to San Diego, many believed their positions were uncertain. The Giants’ search for a new manager was hindered by the uncertainty in San Diego, but Melvin has emerged as the frontrunner in San Francisco. League sources indicate that he was assured of being a top candidate before agreeing to the interview process.

The stylistic differences between Preller and Melvin became more apparent as the Padres struggled during the 2023 season. These differences caused a significant disconnect and were considered an open secret in the baseball industry. Owner Peter Seidler’s desires played a role in the decision to retain both Preller and Melvin after a less than stellar season.

Preller refused to comment on whether the Padres would allow Melvin to explore other job opportunities. However, Melvin is currently under contract with the Padres until 2024 and is considered their manager for the upcoming season. The Giants’ president of baseball operations, Farhan Zaidi, has already interviewed internal candidates and sought permission for others, but Melvin’s availability has had a significant impact on the selection process.

Melvin, a Bay Area native and former Giants catcher, has a history of working with Zaidi during their time in Oakland. The two collaborated for three years, with Melvin serving as the manager and Zaidi as the assistant GM. Additionally, Melvin is highly regarded by key members of the Giants’ ownership group. The Giants began their search by interviewing four internal candidates and have expressed interest in former catchers from other teams.

The Padres may have several reasons for allowing the Giants to interview Melvin. Preller and Melvin clashed regularly, and Preller may want to find a manager who aligns with his approach. Ryan Flaherty, the Padres’ bench coach and offensive coordinator, is seen as a potential future manager and is favored by Preller. Furthermore, the Padres are likely attempting to cut costs after a disappointing season, during which they spent over $250 million in payroll. Melvin is one of the highest-paid managers in baseball, and his salary obligations would transfer to the Giants if he were to leave.

It remains uncertain whether the Padres would seek compensation if Melvin were to join a divisional rival. In the past, similar swap deals have been made involving off-field personnel. Melvin’s potential departure raises questions for the Padres, who are trying to recover from a disastrous season. If Melvin doesn’t get the Giants job, it could impact his tenure in San Diego. This situation also puts Preller under scrutiny, as he might soon be looking for his fifth manager.

As of now, Melvin’s interviews for the Giants position have implications for both teams and could signal significant changes in the NL West.