Weekend NHL rankings: Who’s had it worse so far, the Oilers or the Flames?

It’s the Battle of Alberta! Discover which of these two fan bases is currently experiencing the highest level of misery. This situation is far from what was expected. Prior to the season, the Edmonton Oilers were seen as a team that had all the pieces in place for a successful Cup run. The Calgary Flames, on the other hand, had shed the negative influences of the past and were ready to make their mark in the wide-open Pacific Division. The stage was set for an exciting Heritage Classic game that would establish the superiority of one team over the other. Unfortunately, the game did not live up to expectations. Although it was entertaining and had all the usual elements of an outdoor game, it failed to ignite the passions of the two struggling teams. Everything else about this season has been equally uneventful for both fan bases, as both teams find themselves tied for 30th place in the NHL with just five points each. So, let’s dive into the factors that contribute to the misery of each team and determine which team has it worse: Edmonton or Calgary?

5. Expectations: The Flames had high hopes entering the season, aiming to secure a playoff spot or possibly more. However, the Oilers were considered Cup favorites. Advantage: Oilers.

4. Lingering Narrative: For the Oilers, it’s the repeated criticism that they are a high-scoring team lacking defensive effort and the necessary grit to win tough games. For the Flames, it’s the disappointment of ousting successful coach Darryl Sutter only to perform even worse. Advantage: Flames.

3. Lowest Moment: While the Flames suffered a tough 6-2 loss to the Detroit Red Wings, it doesn’t compare to the Oilers’ opening night debacle, an 8-1 loss to the Vancouver Canucks, or a 7-4 loss to the Minnesota Wild. Advantage: Oilers.

2. Internal Conflict: The Oilers appear to be relatively united despite recent frustrations, as highlighted by Evander Kane’s post-game interview. Meanwhile, the Flames have experienced dissension in their ranks, as evidenced by Nikita Zadarov’s curious comments about their former coach. Advantage: Flames.

1. Existential Fear: Oilers fans worry that the team is wasting the talents of their championship core, potentially leading to the departure of superstars Leon Draisaitl and Connor McDavid when their contracts expire. Flames fans fear being stuck in mediocrity due to long-term contracts that may not live up to expectations. Advantage: No clear winner here. Both fears are valid in their own ways.

With a disappointing tie between the two teams, which is not acceptable, we turn to the tie-breaker: last night’s game. Therefore, congratulations (or apologies) to Flames fans, as you currently hold the title of the most miserable fan base in Alberta. However, this ranking may change in the coming games.

Now, let’s move on to the Top Five teams with the best chances of winning the Stanley Cup. In recent news, the legendary Joe Thornton announced his retirement at the age of 44 after an impressive career spanning 24 seasons. Check out Fluto and Eric’s analysis of his legacy.

5. Carolina Hurricanes (5-4-0, -2 true goals differential*): The Hurricanes are back on track with two consecutive wins, thanks in part to the return of Andrei Svechnikov. However, their victories over the Seattle Kraken and San Jose Sharks are not particularly impressive. It’s important to consider long-term prospects, and contenders like the Boston Bruins, Toronto Maple Leafs, and New York Islanders are knocking on the door. The Hurricanes need to step up their game.

4. Colorado Avalanche (6-2-0, +7): The Avalanche suffered back-to-back losses, both by identical 4-0 scores. These defeats against struggling teams are concerning, but the return of Cale Makar from a scary collision gave some reassurance.

3. New Jersey Devils (5-2-1, +4): The Devils faced an unfortunate setback with the suspension of their captain Nico Hischier after a high hit from Connor Clifton. Nevertheless, they showcased their strength by securing an impressive win over the Minnesota Wild without their leader. These two teams will face each other again soon, after what seems like an unnecessarily long travel period.

2. Dallas Stars (4-1-1, +2): Despite suffering their first non-shootout loss against the Toronto Maple Leafs, the Stars’ previous accomplishments speak for themselves. Facing the best goaltender in history, they managed to score a goal and remain a strong contender for the Cup. With upcoming games against the struggling Alberta teams, they have an opportunity to regain momentum.

1. Vegas Golden Knights (8-0-1, +13): The Golden Knights may have had their win streak ended by the Chicago Blackhawks, but their overall performance has been outstanding. Accumulating 17 out of a possible 18 points is a remarkable achievement. However, their reliance on shootouts and the quality of their wins must be considered, particularly as they prepare to face the Colorado Avalanche. Their top position remains tenuous.

*Goals differential without shootout results, deviating from the NHL’s counting methodology.

Not Ranked: Boston Bruins: Bruins fans, we hear your concerns. Despite your team’s impressive 7-0-1 record, they did not make the top five in last week’s rankings. So, why aren’t they included? Well, although they allowed me to question their capabilities with a shocking collapse against the Anaheim Ducks, ultimately losing in overtime after blowing a late two-goal lead, their overall performance is still commendable. With a record better than most teams on the list, including their strong performance last season, the Bruins are a force to be reckoned with. However, we must also acknowledge that their success is not surprising given their previous accomplishments. They are not a dark horse emerging from nowhere.

Reference

Sarah Anderson

Sarah Anderson dives into the fast-paced world of NHL hockey. Her coverage includes game analysis, player spotlights, and the latest news from the ice. Sarah’s dedication to the sport ensures that hockey enthusiasts stay informed about the NHL’s thrilling action.